Skip to main content

Table 2 Outcomes of the mindfulness-based intervention compared to the control group

From: Feasibility and effectiveness of the mindfulness-based stress reduction programs on relieving burnout of healthcare providers during the COVID-19 pandemic: a pilot randomized controlled trial in China

 

Intervention group

M ± SD

Control group

M ± SD

Difference ± SD (95%CI)

Ftime

(p, partial η2)

Fgroup

(p, partial η2)

Finteraction

(p, partial η2)

Cohen’s d (95%CI)

Mindfulness

 Pre-intervention

122.34

 ± 12.95

123.66

 ± 12.38

     

 Mid-intervention

127.43

 ± 14.87

123.88

 ± 12.30

3.55 ± 2.58

(− 1.56, 8.66)

2.848

(0.094, 0.026)

0.211

(0.647, 0.002)

10.291

(0.002, 0.088)

0.48

(0.10, 0.85)

 Post-intervention

132.07

 ± 19.33

122.54

 ± 12.27

9.54 ± 3.06

(3.46, 15.61)

2.255

(0.136, 0.021)

2.086

(0.152, 0.019)

28.071

(< 0.001, 0.208)

0.91

(0.52, 1.30)

Emotion regulation

Cognitive reappraisal

 Pre-intervention

29.46

 ± 5.04

28.41

 ± 5.52

     

 Mid-intervention

30.05

 ± 5.69

28.50

 ± 6.94

1.55 ± 1.20

(− 0.82, 3.93)

3.501

(0.064, 0.032)

1.528

(0.219, 0.014)

1.704

(0.195, 0.016)

0.11

(− 0.26, 0.48)

 Post-intervention

31.52

 ± 6.11

27.52

 ± 7.09

4.00 ± 1.25

(1.52, 6.48)

3.643

(0.059, 0.033)

5.851

(0.017, 0.052)

10.438

(0.002, 0.089)

0.62

(0.24, 1.00)

Expressive suppression

 Pre-intervention

12.62

 ± 4.51

13.59

 ± 3.94

     

 Mid-intervention

13.45

 ± 4.26

13.96

 ± 5.09

− 0.52 ± .89

(− 2.28, 1.24)

0.014

(0.906, <0.001)

0.926

(0.338, 0.009)

0.338

(0.562, 0.003)

0.13

(− 0.24, 0.50)

 Post-intervention

12.82

 ± 4.90

14.25

 ± 4.62

− 1.43 ± .90

(− 3.21, 0.36)

1.486

(0.226, 0.014)

2.416

(0.123, 0.022)

0.520

(0.472, 0.005)

0.13

(− 0.24, 0.50)

Affect

Positive affect

 Pre-intervention

31.00

 ± 6.66

30.61

 ± 5.65

     

 Mid-intervention

31.36

 ± 6.92

30.38

 ± 7.99

0.98 ± 1.41

(− 1.82, 3.78)

0.616

(0.434, 0.006)

0.353

(0.554, 0.003)

1.159

(0.284, 0.011)

0.11

(− 0.26, 0.48)

 Post-intervention

33.79

 ± 7.52

29.66

 ± 7.38

4.13 ± 1.41

(1.33, 6.92)

0.264

(0.608, 0.002)

3.120

(0.080, 0.028)

11.106

(0.001, 0.094)

0.69

(0.31, 1.07)

Negative affect

       

 Pre-intervention

22.89

 ± 7.48

22.96

 ± 7.31

     

 Mid-intervention

21.32

 ± 6.59

21.96

 ± 7.08

− 0.64 ± 1.29

(− 3.20, 1.92)

0.099

(0.754, 0.001)

0.728

(0.396, 0.007)

0.008

(0.929, < .0.001)

0.10

(− 0.27, 0.47)

 Post-intervention

20.68

 ± 6.26

22.50

 ± 6.82

− 1.82 ± 1.24

(− 4.27, 0.63)

0.392

(0.533, 0.004)

1.896

(0.171, 0.017)

1.813

(0.181, 0.017)

0.32

(− 0.05, 0.69)

Burnout

Emotional exhaustion

 Pre-intervention

20.96

 ± 10.81

22.04

 ± 11.10

     

 Mid-intervention

19.54

 ± 11.41

21.68

 ± 12.62

− 2.14 ± 2.27

(− 6.65, 2.36)

0.983

(0.324, 0.009)

0.647

(0.423, 0.006)

0.901

(0.345, 0.008)

0.12

(− 0.25, 0.49)

 Post-intervention

16.75

 ± 11.55

21.29

 ± 11.35

− 4.54 ± 2.16

(− 8.82, − 0.25)

0.890

(0.348, 0.008)

1.866

(0.175, 0.017)

5.401

(0.022, 0.048)

0.40

(0.02, 0.77)

Depersonalization

 Pre-intervention

5.11

 ± 5.82

6.82

 ± 5.58

     

 Mid-intervention

5.29

 ± 5.08

7.68

 ± 6.78

− 2.39 ± 1.19

(− 4.76, − 0.03)

0.910

(0.342, 0.008)

1.891

(0.172, 0.017)

 <0.001

(0.986, < 0.001)

0.15

(− 0.22, 0.52)

 Post-intervention

5.14

 ± 5.57

7.45

 ± 6.34

− 2.30 ± 1.13

(− 4.54, − 0.07)

0.454

(0.502, 0.004)

2.874

(0.093, 0.026)

0.232

(0.631, 0.002)

0.13

(− 0.24, 0.50)

Personal accomplishment

 Pre-intervention

34.07

 ± 9.67

32.55

 ± 9.23

     

Mid-intervention

34.75

 ± 10.62

31.27

 ± 10.60

3.48 ± 2.00

(− 0.49, 7.46)

0.733

(0.394, 0.007)

0.027

(0.871, <0.001)

0.497

(0.482, 0.005)

0.25

(− 0.12, 0.62)

 Post-intervention

35.30

 ± 10.20

29.54

 ± 10.90

5.77 ± 1.99

(1.82, 9.72)

0.009

(0.926, < 0.001)

1.417

(0.236, 0.013)

7.051

(0.009, 0.062)

0.54

(0.16, 0.92)